Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It is a bench - for sitting on.

That's presumably the original intent behind it.

But humans are an innovative bunch, so they start using things for all sorts of purposes that they were not originally designed for.

Some of these uses are deemed, whether everyone agrees with that or not, to be bad. Sometimes clearly so, sometimes less.

Should it be bad that a homeless has a relatively comfortable space to sleep ? Maybe if that happens too much, other people can't use the benches any more.

If a bench is unoccupied it makes for a good skaterail. It's already outside and presumably dirty, so where's the harm ? But maybe some people will be deterred to sit if it's always being skated on.

Maybe the graffiti makes the bench look lot's better ? But then that's subjective.

Drug dealing is bad. But I can remember at least one occasion where I was able to lean a heavy thing I was carrying on the bench and prevent it from falling over, by temporarily strapping it to a crease in the bench I was sitting on. Presumably like one of those that are used to hide small drug stashes.

I don't think it's as clear cut, as you make it out to be. And I agree, that it makes sense to forbid, let's say skating and graffiti on benches that people want to sit on.

I just think that even a simple thing as a bench in a public place can be more than just a bench just by virtue of the amount of creative minds that pass by it each day. And dealing with this creativity by just forbidding it, or designing certain use cases out of it makes for dull society.



If the definition of "dull society" is specifically restricted to the absence of:

* Homeless sleeping on public benches

* Surprise drug stashes in public benches

* Skate grease slathered on public benches

* Organized crime organizations tagging public benches as their territory

Then yes, I agree, what a dull society the Camden bench creates.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: