Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Many people don't consider something "open source" if they can't build it themselves.

Other alternative app stores are the Yandex Store (https://store.yandex.com/) or the Amazon App Store, those include non-free software too.



Yeah, BTW the good thing about these stores is that they install apps normally, by launching the system APK install dialog, instead of the rootkit-style thing Google Play does.


What's the "rootkit style"? My searches for "rootkit style installation google play" did not result in anything meaningful.


It uses special privileges to run the installation in the background. Google Play Services is frequently called a "rootkit" because of stuff like that.


Rootkit-style installing is also possible with F-Droid :)


Yeah, I've seen that option, but I like to keep that as a disabled option :)


Don't forget the Yalp-store, which you can install from F-droid. Yalp can get you all the non-FLOSS software. Like Minecraft PE. ;-)


You can build the app, and to make it functional you could request your own API key, so I think it satisfies the label. Requesting API keys as a regular end user isn't anywhere near being realistic though, so that's not an option for distribution.


From pawadu's response above it sounds like your app would satisfy the requirements if you have a build parameter or similar that lets them specify the key.


There's another discussion thread [1] which takes a strict stance more explicitly: "I don’t see how something that contains a ‘secret’ key [...] can be Free Software. So we just don’t publish such applications."

[1] https://f-droid.org/forums/topic/api-keys-and-free-software-...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: