Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I was surprised by that also. Here's what I found and shared in an earlier comment in this submission.

I asked a friend who has a CPA, but doesn't work in tax law. Their first comment after briefly scanning the legal code is that "disqualified person" is only used within the context of "prohibited transaction". The definition of "prohibited transaction" concerning "disqualified person" doesn't seem to address this case. Instead, it seems to focus on dealing with the Roth IRA assets in a manner to benefits ones accounts outside of the Roth.



Very interesting. The Retirement Industry Trust has a long page:

https://ritaus.org/how-to-avoid-prohibited-transactions/

It's also confusing. In their "do's":

> Don’t provide more than ministerial services (e.g., decision-making) to your IRA or IRA owned entity (e.g., no “sweat equity”);

But in the "Don'ts":

"Do consider using an IRA when you, a relative or friend starts a new business."

Here's another writeup around that provision by a CFP:

https://www.kitces.com/blog/self-directed-ira-prohibited-tra...

Key quote:

> "However, if someone establishes a self-directed IRA with the aim to invest IRA dollars into a small private held business that they control or own – such that the business entity, and/or their role in the business, can cause it to be a disqualified person – there is a risk that allocating IRA dollars to own that business can cause the IRA itself to become disqualified (and treated as fully distributed as a taxable event). After all, if the IRA puts money into the business, and the business then uses that money to pay a salary to the IRA owner (as an officer of the business), the IRA owner has effectively used the assets of the IRA to enrich themselves."

That addresses the self-dealing part of a transaction like this that would be a common-sense red flag. This is all clear as mud; I'm definitely confused enough that I'll be asking my CPA for a recommendation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: