Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

To be fair, the word used was "control". The HN title is, once again, distorting the content of the submission. The author's discussion is focused on media consolidation and the slow death of local news, not Big Tech's control over what people consume. (Though she does cite Big Tech's practice of censoring independent news sources.)


Great documentary on the decline of local news and battle against social media that aired on PBS about Storm Lake, Iowa: https://www.pbs.org/independentlens/documentaries/storm-lake...


I don’t think distorting is the right term as the HN title is the subtitle for the article.


Yes, but without the title preceding it, the statement loses its context.

It baffles me when people want to override authors on titles. Sure, sometimes it might make sense to do so, but most of the time the author is the person in the best position to present and explain what she has written.


"The Monopoly On Your Mind, Part 1: Consolidation Craze & Illusion of Choice"

I don't see what context this adds.


I do.

If this was the HN title I would not necessarily think about Big Tech.

Then when I began reading the blog post I would quickly see it is about media consolidation and the decline of local news, not about Big Tech intermediary (middleman) control over the delivery of media that some other entity has produced.

This is only Part 1, so there may be more about Big Tech in Parts 2 and 3.


> The HN title is, once again, distorting the content of the submission.

Getting soooo tired of users modifying headlines to promote their agenda.


Moderators also modify the titles.


But not to promote an agenda.


How is this promoting an agenda? I hate when people hate on frivolous things when it doesn’t fit their agenda. Republicans called this out and it was largely ignore (I know, i was one of them calling it out) and now people are upset they used the subtitle instead of the more liberal friendly main title?


> The author's discussion is focused on media consolidation and the slow death of local news, not Big Tech's control over what people consume.

The HN title should at least be representative of the content.


Seems like it is to me


Do people email moderators asking them to change titles?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: