Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> "and the vertical bar is not a scroll bar." These words were added to get around prior art. All Google would need to do is allow its position indicator to also function as a scroll bar and this patent doesn't apply.

Interesting to note that on OS/X Lion, the indicator DOES function as a scrollbar. And when it doesn't on IOS, it bugs me (try flicking through a very long document with the non-grabable indicator on iOS). Sounds like Apple has been granted a patent for a less-usable variant of an existing technology.



Also of note is that most disappearing scroll indicators in Android are scroll bars; if you can drag on the indicator before it disappears, you can use it to quickly scroll large distances in a big document or list.


I was thinking the same thing. But my current phone does not do that any more. I liked that feature. Maybe now Google will be forced to bring it. :)


How can you possible be granted a patent for the removal of a function from an existing idea?

Can I take away the headlights from a car and patent it as something new?


headlights of a headlights-less car probably qualify.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: