Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
In 1850, America was like China today (boston.com)
11 points by charzom on Aug 27, 2007 | hide | past | favorite | 12 comments


I learned this in my History of Technology course a few years back... Ever since I've been very amused by the outrage over China's disrespect for "intellectual property" on sites like Slashdot.


really? They had forced abortions and internal passports that dictated where in the country you could live? And the US government ran tanks over people who protested?


Nope. They gave you smallpox-infested blankets, made you walk thousands of miles to the reservation, and massacred you if you resisted.


These things _did_ occur, but they are not the cause of the demise of the Native American.

The mere _arrival_ of Europeans, who carried diseases to which Native Americans were not immune, doomed them. These diseases were rapidly spread to any who traded with Europeans and thence to the innermost regions of North (and South) America. Most Native Americans died of transmitted European diseases long before they had any any opportunity to glimpse a "white man".

The Native Americans were so decimated by the time of the massacres and reservations that entire tribes had to migrate and merge, losing their unique identities, in order to merely survive.


America was communist in the 19th century?

I learn something new every day.


China is communist today?

I learn something new every day.


According to the CIA factbook, China is a communist state.

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/...


That entry is under "Government Type", not under "Economy". The relevant passage from the Economy section is "China's economy during the last quarter century has changed from a centrally planned system that was largely closed to international trade to a more market-oriented economy that has a rapidly growing private sector and is a major player in the global economy."

This may be confusing, because communism is both a political and an economic system. China could best be described as a one-party communist state with a free-market capitalist economy. However, the article is the economy, not the government. These complaints wouldn't be an issue if China was really Communist - the recent uproar has been about a lack of government regulation in product manufacturer, while a truly communist government would manufacturer all the goods itself.


Don't forget that the Chinese government has a minority stake in many major Chinese companies. This is a kind of partial communism, at least.


So does Warren Buffett, but you wouldn't claim that the Chinese economy is partial Buffettism, eh? ;-)


I think it would only be Buffettism if Warren Buffett was one of the Chinese oligarchs...


I learn something new everyday too ;)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: