Those lists are great but they lack an important part — some signal of quality. How would a user know if the book is any good? Or if it shows best practices? Especially if it's meant for beginners.

It would be of course unreasonable to expect the author of the list to review each and every book but maybe users could post reviews? Or vote? Or just comment?

This is precisely what I came to this comment section looking for. I'd like to know which of these books HN users would suggest over others.

You have an old link for "Natural Language Processing with Python" - the NLTK book. It's moved to http://nltk.org/book/

Each book is missing its edition and year of release.

It'd be great for a download button for offline reading.

Is it possible to search within the documents?

Any recommendations? Thanks

would be awesome pdf format for the books :)

Print to PDF?